Safe Money Radio

Why a Big Balance Is Not the Same as a Safe Retirement

A large savings balance feels safe. You worked for it. You watched it climb. You checked the statement and felt a little steadier every year, the number moved in the right direction. That feeling is real, and it is earned. It is also not the same thing as a safe retirement.

by, Brett Blake
Oct 06, 2026

About This Blog

A balance sits there. It does not send you a check. It does not adjust for the cost of living. It does not promise to still be there in year twenty of a retirement that could last thirty. Real safety in retirement comes from something the balance alone cannot give you. It comes from income the pile pays you every month for the rest of your life.

On this episode of Safe Money Radio, Brett Blake talks with Steve Dybwad, a Retirement Income Specialist based in Nineveh, Indiana, and the original voice of Safe Money Radio out of Muncie. Steve has been licensed for more than 50 years. He started as a teenager, spent years as a stockbroker, and now helps people near retirement do something different with their money. He helps them turn it into income.

Their conversation surfaces six questions that separate a big balance from a safe retirement.

1. What does your current lifestyle actually cost every month?

Steve starts every client conversation the same way. He does not ask how big the savings balance is. He asks what it takes to live the life you are already living. Housing, food, insurance, the basics. That monthly number becomes the target. Everything else builds around it. Without that number, no retirement plan feels real, no matter how big the balance looks.

2. What is the least amount of money it takes to fund that lifestyle for life?

Once you know the monthly cost, Steve flips the usual planning question. Most people ask how much they need in total. He asks about the smallest pile that could produce that monthly income for as long as you live. That reframing changes what the plan needs to do. It also often surprises people. They discover they already have enough, or nearly enough, to build a base of dependable income for the essentials. A big balance without that base is still exposed. A modest balance with that base often feels safer.

3. Does your plan depend on the market cooperating every single year?

For years people have leaned on the idea that you can pull about 4 percent of your savings each year and be fine. That guideline comes from retirement researcher William Bengen, who introduced it in the October 1994 Journal of Financial Planning article "Determining Withdrawal Rates Using Historical Data." His original figure was 4.15 percent, based on simulating 30-year retirements with a 50/50 stock and bond portfolio using U.S. market data going back to 1926 (source: Bill Bengen's official site). Bengen later revised his safe rate upward to 4.7 percent in his 2025 book A Richer Retirement (source: Morrissey Wealth Management summary).

Steve explains why that rule leaves many people uneasy. A rough stretch in the first years of retirement can shrink the balance fast while you are also pulling money out. Financial firms have a name for that danger. It is called sequence-of-returns risk, and Thrivent describes it as concentrated in the first decade of retirement, when portfolio balances are largest and most exposed to market downturns. Charles Schwab warns that it "could take a huge slice out of your retirement income" for people close to retiring.

The 4 percent idea is a guideline, not a promise. When your safety depends on the market cooperating every year, the balance can look big and still not feel safe.

4. Who is really paying the fee, you or the insurance company?

Steve makes a clean point about how people get paid in financial services. If you buy stocks, bonds, or mutual funds through a broker, you generally pay fees out of your own account. Those fees compound against your balance year after year, and they chip away at the safety the balance seemed to offer. With a fixed indexed annuity, the commission is paid by the insurance company and does not come out of your deposit. The full amount you put in stays working for you from day one. Knowing who pays whom changes how you compare options.

5. Are you rearranging the money you already own, or being sold something new?

Steve uses a picture that sticks. Most people do not need to add money to the pile. They need to rearrange the financial furniture in the house they already own. Move some money into the room that pays the bills. Move some into the room that keeps growing. Move some into the room that pays you for the rest of your life. Nothing gets thrown out. The room just works better. A big balance in the wrong rooms leaves you exposed. The same balance, arranged with intention, can carry you the rest of the way.

6. Is it truly too late, or have you just not looked at the numbers?

If you are in your late fifties or sixties and you feel behind, Steve has real encouragement to offer. He has worked with late starters for decades. A focused plan can still build dependable income even when the calendar feels tight. The worst move is to avoid the numbers because you are afraid of what you will see. Most people who finally sit down and look find they have more room to maneuver than they thought. A balance you have not planned around cannot protect you the way a balance you have put to work can.

FAQ

Why is a big balance not the same as a safe retirement? A balance is a number. Safety in retirement is about the income that number can produce, month after month, for as long as you live. Steve Dybwad makes the point that the pile alone does not pay your bills. Only the income it generates does.

Is the 4 percent rule safe? It is a guideline, not a guarantee. William Bengen created it in 1994 using 30-year simulations. It depends on market performance and how long you live. A rough stretch in the market early in retirement can put the plan under strain through sequence-of-returns risk, which is why many people want a base of dependable income underneath it.

What is a fixed indexed annuity? It is a long-term contract with an insurance company. It offers protection of principal against market losses and the option, often through a rider, to provide guaranteed lifetime income. These products may or may not be suitable for your situation and are subject to state availability and individual suitability.

Is it too late to plan if I am already in my sixties? No. Steve Dybwad has helped people start in their sixties and still build income they can count on for life. A focused plan can make a meaningful difference even when you feel behind.

Where To Start

Start with your own numbers. Run the free WIYN calculator at brettblake.annuity.com. It takes about three minutes and shows the gap between the income you want and the income you have. When you are ready to talk it through, book a Retirement Clarity Session with Brett. No obligation, no pressure. Brett is a licensed insurance agent and may recommend an annuity if it fits.

Worry Less. Live Longer.

About the host

Brett A. Blake is the CEO of Annuity.com, Inc. and host of Safe Money Radio. He built a nearly $1B business, starting near $50M, before stepping into retirement income education full-time. Brett is a licensed insurance agent, not a CPA or tax attorney. He lives in Gilbert, Arizona with his wife Erin and their five children and three grandchildren.

About the guest

Steve Dybwad is a Retirement Income Specialist based in Nineveh, Indiana, and the original voice of Safe Money Radio out of Muncie. Licensed for more than 50 years, he spent years as a stockbroker before shifting his focus to preserving and distributing money for people near retirement. Steve is a licensed insurance agent, not a CPA or tax attorney.

Follow Safe Money Radio

Follow Brett Blake

LinkedIn: @brettblake | Retirement tools: brettblake.annuity.com | Email: brett.blake@annuity.com

Follow Steve Dybwad

Website: stephenjdybwad.com | LinkedIn: @stephen-dybwad | Facebook: @stephenjdybwad | Annuity.com agent page: stephendybwad.annuity.com

#RetirementIncome #SafeMoney #GuaranteedIncome #Annuities #RetirementPlanning #FixedIndexedAnnuity #LifetimeIncome #RetirementReady #IncomePlanning #SafeMoneyRadio

DISCLAIMER:

Safe Money Radio is for educational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice. Products discussed may or may not be suitable for your situation and are subject to state availability and individual suitability.

Any guarantees discussed are backed by the claims-paying ability of the issuing insurance company. Guarantees are not government-backed or provided by Annuity.com, Inc.

By submitting your information through any Safe Money Radio call to action, you consent to be contacted by a licensed insurance agent about products and services that may include annuities.

Annuity.com, Inc. and Brett A. Blake are compensated through commissions and other consideration paid by insurance carriers on policies sold. Neither is a fee-only advisor. Brett is a licensed insurance agent, not a CPA or tax attorney.

Annuity.com, Inc. is a licensed insurance agency. National Producer Number (NPN): 21086345. Doing business in Florida and California as Annuity.com Insurance Marketing, CA License No. 6013124. In New York, licensed as Annuity.com Insurance Solutions, License No. LA-1860109.

GUEST DISCLOSURE:

Steve Dybwad is a podcast guest appearing in his individual professional capacity. Views expressed on this episode are his own and do not necessarily reflect those of Safe Money Radio, Brett A. Blake, or Annuity.com, Inc.

Related Blog

Duis mi velit, auctor vitae leo a, luctus congue dolor. Nullam at velit quis tortor malesuada ultrices vitae vitae lacus. Curabitur tortor purus, tempor in dignissim eget, convallis in lorem.

You Get One Shot at Retirement Income: Jeremy Keil on the 5 Steps to Get It Right

You spent forty years learning how to save. Almost no one taught you what to do with the money once the paychecks stop. That gap is the reason so many people reach retirement with a healthy balance and still feel unsure every month. In this episode of Safe Money Radio, host Brett Blake sits down with Jeremy Keil, a CFP, CFA, and CKA who has spent more than twenty years helping people near retirement turn their savings into income. Keil is the author of Retire Today and the creator of the Mr. Retirement YouTube channel. Here is what he covered, in plain language, for anyone trying to turn a lifetime of saving into a paycheck that lasts.

Annuities 101: John Stevenson on What Buyers Should Know

Most people who sit down with an annuity agent see one option, maybe two, and are told it’s the best available. John Stevenson built his career by doing the opposite. In this episode of Safe Money Radio, host Brett Blake talks with Stevenson, a Certified Financial Fiduciary®, author of Guaranteed Retirement, and host of The Guaranteed Retirement Guy show on YouTube. By his own count, Stevenson meets with more than 600 new people a year, most of them between 50 and 65.

A Little Planning Goes a Long Way: Bart Catmull on Retiring Without the Worry

You can do the hard part right and still not feel it. You save for years. You reach retirement with a healthy balance. And the worry shows up anyway, on the first of every month. If that sounds familiar, this episode is for you.

What to Ask Before You Buy an Indexed Annuity

Moore's short answer to this week's question: check the financial strength of the insurance company first. Everything else, including the rate, comes after. In this week's episode of Safe Money Radio, host Brett A. Blake sits down with Sheryl J. Moore, President & CEO of Moore Market Intelligence and Founder & CEO of Wink, Inc., as she walks through what to check, how guaranteed lifetime income works, and how to set realistic expectations.

View All